10/10 - SHOELESSJOE1919

10/10 - Mounfro

9/10 - Karloth Valois

9/10
Can be slow, but is brutal at short range. Based on Warlord's Black Sea Ruleset. Good fun with a small model count so easy to get going with a painted set of models - ftrobbie

9/10 - WyldRaider

8.7/10
fully painted + dwarf faction fully painted - wolverine1977

8.25/10 - hans4rd

8/10 - GingerNinjaNicko

8/10 - CardboardAnt

8/10
Basilean, Orc, Dwarf and (soon) Empire of Dust fleets. Captivated by the minis, but the game is good too - mattprice

8/10 - Napalmhead

8/10 - BobaFett27

8/10
Very good - enjoy playing and would suggest it for any seas battles fan. Which the critical damage was a bit quicker and the general damage rolls had more dice involved but the mechanics based on Black Sails are definitely enjoyable and work well! - AngryJoeShow

8/10 - skymandr

8/10 - Drizzl3

8/10 - Toxic_Rat

8/10 - Anti11

7.54667/10 - billybobdozer

7.5/10
Much of this resembles GDW's sadly defunct ManOWar miniatures game. An example is Armada's Orcish Bloodrunners - they are very similar to ManoWar's Drillakillas. Armada's miniatures are bigger, more detailed and the rules are about the same in terms of complexity. Armada does not track hit locations like ManOWar and the navies are more symmetrical. The miniatures are gorgeous. They are all resin and paint beautifully and they look stunning on the table. The game plays smoothly and is a lot of fun. However, some of the components are not that great. The counters denoting speed are too garish and hard to read. Mantic games also made the inexplicable decision to use wooden laser cut counters for race specific upgrades which are again small and hard to read. The ship cards show a top down view of the miniature which is helpful for assembling them, but that is about it. I would have preferred a more evocative side illustration of ship instead. Mantic Games also missed an opportunity to colour code the cannons on the cards, so unless you memorized what colour matches which cannon, you will be looking this stuff up regularly. There is also no separate charts - you have to scan and print them from the rulebook. Overall, its a fun game with beautiful ships (the Basileans look just stunning!) in need of a component upgrade, namely one rule book instead of three, new admin counters/markers, and upgraded ship cards. - EHEM

7/10 - tata_duende

7/10 - leanderuk

7/10 - Dasbeets

7/10 - Cthulhu1

7/10 - wolfpack95

6.5/10 - Scuttlebutt

6/10 - lord_erkenbrand

6/10 - Valander

4/10
We played through the battle, though honestly didn't understand it too much as the demo giver didn't us a lot of reasons why we were doing things, we just did them. The models we played with were beautiful of course. My daughter though wasn't a fan of the game. - ooogene